Not your Grandma's Macaroni and Cheese.
Friday, February 18, 2011 at 5:00AM | Taneasha 
Or perhaps it is. The inspiration for my version of Mac n’ Cheese does, in fact, originate with my grandmother. Although she never actually made it for me, my dad improved upon her recipe and fed it to us over the years. I have since made changes of my own, until getting to where it is now. Perfection. That’s right, I said perfection, and I’m standing by that. This isn’t made with a cheese sauce or topped with bread crumbs, it’s not the mushy gloop you might find at the deli or on a buffet, and it certainly isn’t that neon orange Krap from a box. It’s hot, bubbly, cheesy, bacony goodness, like you’ve never experienced before.
What you’ll need:
1 ¼ cups each, of 3 different kinds of cheese*
½ pound bacon*
1 pound macaroni
4 or 5 green onions
1 ½ cups milk
Liberal amounts of salt and pepper
*Ingredient notes: Use good quality cheese. Don’t buy the pre-grated stuff. Grate your own. For a commercial brand, I like Tillamook, but I also like to buy local and imported cheese from the cheese monger. You can get pretty good stuff from the cheese counter at most grocery stores these days.
As for the bacon, use one that’s just a regular slice. The thickly sliced stuff isn’t the best in this dish. Also, I am very passionate about the treatment (or mistreatment) of pigs, so please buy bacon that comes from humanely raised pigs if you can. Niman Ranch and Beelers are a couple of good examples.
Onto the actual cooking. I like to cook bacon in the oven. It’s easy to make, and easy cleanup. Line a sheet pan with aluminum foil and lay out your bacon slices. That way, when it’s all done, and the bacon grease solidifies, you can just take the foil off and throw the whole thing away. Slide the pan into a cold oven and then turn it to 350°. If your husband is around, you might want to make two pans so that you'll still have enough after he's finished snitching.
Now is a good time to chop your green onions and grate the cheese. The combination of cheeses I used was Colby Jack, Extra Sharp Cheddar, and an Apple Walnut Smoked Cheddar.
Ok, back to the bacon. The thickness of the slices can really affect the time it will take to cook. After it’s been in for about 12 to 15 minutes, start to check on it. You might even want to flip the slices over. To me, bacon is not cooked until it’s crisp, so it should look about like this:
Move it to some paper towels to drain. For the pasta, fill a pan with plenty of salted water, and bring it to a boil. Follow the package directions, but make sure the pasta is al dente. It’s going to cook some more in the oven, so you don’t want it too soft now. Drain the macaroni and rinse it with cold water. After allowing the excess water to drain off, pour the noodles into your casserole dish, drizzle with about 2 tablespoons of olive oil, and stir to coat.
Now, let’s chop our bacon.
If your oven is not already preheated to 350° from cooking the bacon, do so now. On top of the macaroni, sprinkle salt and freshly cracked pepper. Reserving about ¼ cup of each of the cheeses, spread the rest on top, mixing them together as you do so. Set aside a couple tablespoons each of the bacon and green onions, and throw the rest into the pot.
Now stir it all together until everything is evenly distributed. Drizzle the milk over the top, covering as much area as you can.
Top with the remaining cheese and press the mixture softly into the pan with your hand.
At this point, you want to cover the pan, but some steam needs to escape as well. My dish has a lid, so I like to fold up a piece of foil to place under it, which creates a bit of a crack.
If you’re covering your dish with foil, just poke a few little holes in it after you’ve got it in place. Bake for about 45 minutes, or until it looks like this:
When you put a spoon down the inside of the pan to the bottom, there should be very little or no liquid down there. That’s how you’ll know it’s done. If there is still liquid down there, simply remove the cover and bake for a few more minutes.
Allow to rest for a good ten minutes before serving. It’ll be the hardest thing you’ve ever had to do, but it really is worth it.
Garnish each portion with a sprinkling of the remaining bacon and green onions and serve with your favorite vegetable. You’ve got to have something nutritious on the plate, right? I went for roasted asparagus.
If you have leftovers, freeze them in individual servings, and you’ll never have to feed your kids (or yourself) that artificially flavored and colored stuff again.
Have a macaroni and cheese recipe you think can outdo mine? Without posting the whole recipe, tell me what's special about yours and why I should try it. The one that interests me most, I'll make and feature here on our blog.
Reader Comments (6)
Hey friend...Wow! This post brings back delicious memories and makes my mouth water. I remember eating this at your Dad's house over a decade ago. I thought it was perfection then, so if you've improved it since then...I can't wait to make this for me and my fam. (Mostly for me though). Thx for the recipe!
Sprinkle a little pinch of Chinese mustard over the cheese after you grate it, and kind of toss it in with the cheese.
I start mine with a roux of bacon fat (southern gravy style) seasoned with a ton of garlic, and I use enough black pepper to make it speckled. And bacon on top, of course.
I'd never thought of green onions! I've always gone for the monochrome look, but that looks lovely and bright! And light. Does it feel a little less stick-to-your-ribs than the typical mac?
I do think it's a bit lighter this way. It's not so rich. The green onions are an awesome addition. They really do bring in their own layer of flavor and color. I've made it with regular onion before, and didn't care for it, but the green onions are fabulous.
A little trick that yields a creamy but stretchy and less curdled cheese sauce:
Stir the cooked macaroni into the white sauce followed by the shredded cheese, a handful at a time. The cheese blends into the white sauce during the baking and thus, doesn't have a chance to overcook and break.
Another good way to cook bacon is on a cookie sheet with a rack! Place the bacon on the rack, that way the bacon grease can drain onto the cookie sheet, and your bacon stays nice and crispy, and you can save the fat for other things!:)
Can't wait to try this recipe!